What Makes it Green

Home | Energy 10 | HVAC System Selection | Electrical System | Extra Credit

bullet

Below we have listed the current industry practices that are used to lower HVAC cost, increase energy efficiency, lower water usage and improve building thermal efficiency. It is these practices that we recommend using in the development of the HVAC, Electrical and Plumbing system of the building although our design reflects some of these techniques and products we were unable to take full advantage of these practices since the tools we used to develop our systems do not take into account the energy saving systems.

 

Heating & Cooling

 
 
Gas-fired Chiller/Heaters
 
 


 
Definition
A natural-gas powered mechanical appliance that supplies chilled water for air-conditioning or for process cooling, as well as hot water for space heating.
 
Building Use
bullet high-rise office
bullet high-rise apartment
bullet retail
bullet food service
bullet institutional
 
 
Building Type
bullet new
bullet retrofit
 
Development
Status
bullet new technology

Description
Conventional air-conditioning chillers are powered by electricity. Most absorption chiller-heaters are powered by natural gas, although some are powered by hot water or steam, or by heat recovered from sources such as reciprocating and turbine engines or process waste heat. A small amount of electricity is used to power pumps in absorption units. Absorption chillers may be used for both heating and cooling purposes, and may be used to produce chilled water for use in process cooling.

While conventional chillers contain a compressor and utilize vapors such as CFCs or HCFCs as refrigerants, absorption-based chillers comprise an absorber, a generator, a pump and a recuperative heat exchanger, and do not use ozone-depleting chemicals. Instead, the absorption process uses two working fluids and a heat source to provide cooling. The most common working fluids used are water (the refrigerant) and lithium bromide (the absorbent); one model of absorption chiller-heater uses ammonia as the refrigerant and water as the absorbent. Lithium bromide and water are environmentally-benign substances that can be disposed of easily.

Gas-fired, double-effect (two-stage) absorption chillers have greater efficiency and reliability than conventional chillers. Gas-fired absorption chiller-heaters units are credited with a median service life of 23 years by ASHRAE.

Information Sources
American Gas Cooling Center
400 North Capital St. NW
Washington DC
USA 20001
tel 1 202 824 7141
fax 1 202 824 7093

Canadian Gas Association
243 Consumers Road
Suite 2000
North York ON
Canada M2J 5E3
tel 1 416 498 1994
fax 1 419 498 7465
www.cga.ca

Contributing Expert:
W.H (Bill) Hawkins,
Consumers Gas
500 Consumers Road
North York ON
Canada M2J 1P8
tel 1 416 496 7179
fax 1 416 495 8350

   
Benefits
bullet eliminates the use of ozone-depleting refrigerants
bullet reduces air-conditioning costs

 

Limitations
bullet higher initial cost
bullet physical constraints in retrofit applications

 

Application
Absorption units can provide chilled water for air conditioning in hospitals, office buildings, universities and high-rise residential buildings. Absorption chiller-heaters can be advantageous when adding air conditioning to a building since their use adds only marginally to electric capacity requirements. Gas-fired absorption chiller-heaters can also provide hot water for space heating; this application may eliminate the need for a boiler.

Absorption units are heavier, have a different size configuration, and have reject more heat to cooling towers than vapor-compression chillers; these characteristics may negatively impact retrofit applications.

Experience
Absorption chillers have gained greater acceptance since the ozone-depleting characteristics of CFC refrigerants were recognized in the mid 1980s. In those regions with high electricity demand and commodity rates relative to natural gas rates, the use of absorption chiller-heaters is most attractive.

Example Buildings
Green on the Grand

Cost
Absorption chiller-heaters in the 500-ton capacity range are approximately  C$500/ton. This cost must be assessed against the advantages of these units, such as reduced operating costs, lower electrical demand, and smaller space required for mechanical equipment if the chiller eliminates the need for a boiler.

Example Manufacturers
Dunham-Bush
EFI-Ironross, Inc.
678 Belmont Ave W.
Suite 304
Kitchener ON
Canada N2M 1N6
tel 1 519 742 0171
fax 1 519 742 0543

Trane
2727 South Ave
Lacrosse WI
USA 54601
tel 1 608 787 3445
fax 1 608 787 4644
www.trane.com

York International
375 Matheson Blvd. East
Mississauga ON
Canada L4Z 1X8
tel 1 800 964 4985
fax 1 905 890 7618
www.york.com

 

Radiant Heating & Cooling
  
 
Radiant Heating & Cooling
 
Definition
A system to heat and cool buildings that relies primarily on radiation heat transfer. Typically, heated or chilled water is circulated though floor or ceiling panels to condition the space. 
Building Use
bullet high-rise office
bullet residential
bullet low-rise office
bullet high-rise apartment
bullet low-rise apartment
bullet retail
bullet institutional
 
Building Type
bullet new
bullet retrofit
 
Development
Status
bullet mature technology

Description
Conventional radiators have been used for many years to heat buildings. The radiators are located around the building perimeter. Because of the small surface area of the radiators, they must be operated at a high temperature to deliver sufficient heat. Modern systems are different in that they cover a large area of floor or ceiling and operate at temperatures much closer to room air temperature, approximately 15oC in cooling mode and 35 to 50oC in heating mode. The system cannot be operated at lower temperatures in cooling mode without the risk of condensation. The small temperature difference means that about 30% to 50% of the ceiling or almost the entire floor area must be available as heat transfer surface. Ventilation air is provided by a small dedicated ductwork system and works particularly well with displacement ventilation concepts.

Several companies have developed metal radiant panels that can be ceiling mounted, either attached directly to the ceiling or as part of a T-bar suspended ceiling. For floor systems, flexible plastic piping is embedded in the concrete floor or in a gypsum topping on a wooden sub-floor. Ceiling mounted systems are usually best for combined heating and cooling systems. Floor systems are best for heating-only systems (provided the floor isn't covered with heavy carpets). 

The amount of heat transfer depends on the direction of heat flow. Air in contact with a cooled ceiling panel will naturally fall as it is cooled increasing the movement of air over the panel. Conversely, air in contact with a warm ceiling will stratify at the ceiling and have low convective heat transfer. As a guide to system sizing, the total heat transfer rate (combined radiation and convection) is about 11 W/m2/oC temperature difference for cooled ceilings and heated bare floors. This value drops to 
6 W/m2/oC for heated ceilings and cooled floors. Floor coverings such as carpeting reduce the output of heated floors.

Radiant systems are more energy-efficient than air-based systems. They require less parasitic energy (pump and fan energy) to deliver heat. The low operating temperatures mean that boilers can operate more efficiently. Finally, because the walls are radiantly heated, the air temperature can be cooler to achieve the same level of comfort. These lower air temperatures result in lower heat losses to the outdoors. 

Information Sources
Hydronic Radiant Heating and Cooling

Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory

Green on the Grand Final Monitoring Report, report prepared by Enermodal Engineering for Natural Resources Canada, 1998

ASHRAE Symposium on Radiant Heating and Cooling, ASHRAE Transactions DA-00-8-1 to DA-00-8-4 

Woodson, Dodge R., Radiant Heating Systems: Retrofit & Installation. New Jersey: Rigor Press, 1999

Contributing Expert
Richard Lay
Enermodal Engineering Limited
650 Riverbend Drive
Kitchener ON
Canada  N2K 3S2
tel 1 519 743 8777
fax 1 519 743 8778
rlay@enermodal.com

   
Benefits
bullet provides more uniform heating - more uniform heating of room
bullet avoids noise and drafts of air-based HVAC systems
bullet lower parasitic energy consumption (for pumps and fans) lower water increases thermal efficiency of heating plant
bullet lowers air temperature and thus reduces heat loss 

 

Limitations
bullet to prevent condensation on cooling panels, an auxiliary air-conditioning system may be needed to dry the air and meet latent cooling load
bullet higher cost than air-based systems
bullet requires large ceiling area or uncarpeted floor area
bullet requires airtight, energy efficient building envelope

 

Application
Radiant heating and cooling systems can be used in most commercial buildings provided there are not excessive internal heat gains. Because of the limited cooling output of the radiant panels, a radiant cooling system would not be able to maintain comfort conditions in buildings with high lighting loads (jewelry stores) or process loads (industrial facilities). Conversely, radiant systems are the ideal choice in buildings or rooms where air quality is critical (hospitals and operating rooms). With radiant systems, only the ventilation air has to be filtered instead of the complete HVAC system as in air-based systems. 

It is important to minimize internal and solar gains to keep the size (and cost) of cooling panels as small as possible. An interesting exception is atria or other spaces where most of the solar gains are incident on the floor. A radiant cooled floor can remove this heat gain before it gets into the building air. 

Experience
Combined radiant heating and cooling have been successfully used in European countries for more than fifteen years. Non-European examples include the Green on the Grand C2000 office building in Kitchener Ontario and the new Bangkok airport. Green on the Grand uses ceiling mounted panels to cool the entire building. The Bangkok airport has a radiant cooled floor to remove solar gains from the overhead glazing.

The RCMP's central headquarters for Northern Alberta uses radiant heating panels to reduce the heat load around the perimeter of its structure. The building's entrance has two 3-story glass walls that must be kept frost-free. Radiant panels mounted on the ceiling are used in conjunction with a tube radiation system in the floor to counter the heat loss created by the windows.

Example Buildings
YMCA Environmental Learning Centre

Cost:
Ceiling-mounted radiant panels cost about C$100/m2 of panel, installation extra. Radiant floor systems cost about C$65/m2 installed. However, part of this cost is offset by savings in ducting costs. At the Green on the Grand project, the total cost for the HVAC system including radiant panels was  C$210/m2 of floor area or about 20% more than a conventional air-based system. 

Example Manufacturers
Radiant Ceilings:
TWA Panel Systems
10410-172nd Street
Edmonton AB
Canada T5S 1H1 
tel 1 403 489 3338
www.twapanels.ca

Invensys Building Systems
15774 South LaGrange Rd. Suite 119
Orland Park IL
USA 60462
tel 1 708 349 6636
fax 1 708 349 6646
www.siebe-env-controls.com

Radiant Floors:
Stadler Corporation
3 Alfred Circle
Bedford MA
USA 01730
tel 1 781 275 3122
fax 1 781 275 5398
www.stadlercorp.com

Wirsbo Canada Ltd.
655 Park Street
Regina SK
USA S4N 5N1
tel 1 888 994 7726
www.wirsbo.ca

Ventilation & Air Quality

 
 
Displacement Ventilation
  
 
Displacement Ventilator

 
Definition
An air distribution system in which incoming air originates at floor level and rises to exhaust outlets at the ceiling.
 
Building Use
bullet high-rise office
bullet low-rise office
bullet high-rise apartment
bullet low-rise apartment
bullet retail
bullet food service
bullet institutional
bullet arena
 
 
Building Type
bullet new
bullet retrofit
 
Development
Status
bullet mature technology

Description
Incoming air is delivered to interior rooms by way of floor-level vents. This incoming air displaces upper air, which is exhausted through ceiling-level vents. Because displacement ventilation systems typically use 100% outdoor air, air pollutants generated within the building are removed at source and are not recirculated. In addition, heat generated by ceiling level lights is removed, and thus heat is not included when estimating building cooling loads.

Displacement ventilation is applied in several different ways, depending on the method used to deliver incoming air. In typical Scandinavian designs, air is released from wall ducts that run under windows. Air is exhausted through ceiling plenums. If the office is more than five meters wide, one air supply may be insufficient. Additional air supply would be required from interior partitions.

In another application of displacement ventilation, air is supplied through floor plenums with in-floor fans, or from above-floor fans associated with workstation air outlets.

A third method uses ceiling jets to send a vertical column of conditioned air to the floor. This method is often used as a means of personal temperature control.

Information Sources
Healthy Buildings International Inc.

Example Buildings
Surrey Tax Centre
Green on the Grand

Contributing Expert
R. T. Tamblyn
Tamblyn Consulting Services
90 Sheppard Avenue East
North York ON
Canada  M2N 5Y7
tel 1 416 226 6565
fax 1 416 218 2288

   
Benefits
bullet removes internal heat gains and entrain pollutants
bullet captures and removes air pollutants at source

 

Limitations
bullet may add complexity to supply air ducting
bullet it is more difficult to incorporate free cooling
bullet more difficult to remove sensible and latent heat gains because of higher air temperatures

 

Application
Displacement ventilation is typically used in offices and industrial plants. The Scandinavian concept is applied successfully in offices with double-loaded corridors.

The temperature of incoming air must not be much lower than room temperature in order to avoid chilling the occupants. This factor has implications for building energy use. In some conditions, additional air volume must be circulated in order to capture internal sensible heat gains and in order to cool air for dehumidification purposes.

Experience
Although a common practice in Europe, the acceptance of displacement ventilation in North America has been slow because of the conventional placement of ducting at ceiling level. The use of displacement ventilation is increasing, however, as a response to interest in improved indoor air quality.

Cost
The cost of individual control varies from C$1000 to $4000/occupant.

Example Manufacturers
Johnson Controls
507 East Michigan Street
Milwaukee WI
USA  53202
tel 1 414 274 4000
fax 1 414 228 1233
www.jci.com

Tamblyn Consulting Services
90 Sheppard Avenue East
North York ON
Canada  M2N 5Y7
tel 1 416 226 6565
fax 1 416 218 2288

 

Desiccant Cooling/Dehumidification
  
 
 
Definition
The use of chemical (or physical) absorption of water vapor to dehumidify air and reduce the latent cooling load in a building HVAC system.
 
Building Use
bullet high-rise office
bullet low-rise office
bullet high-rise apartment
bullet arena
 
 
Building Type
bullet new
bullet retrofit
 
Development
Status
bullet mature technology

Description
Air conditioning systems are sized for a combination of two cooling loads: latent (air humidity) and sensible (cooling of space air). The latent cooling load can account for as much as 30% to 50% of air conditioning requirements. Conventional, refrigeration-based air conditioning is electrical-energy intensive, and is costly to install and to operate.

Desiccant dehumidification removes humidity from ventilation air. Thus, air conditioning requirements are reduced to meet the demands of sensible cooling and smaller air-conditioning plants are required. Smaller air-handling systems are also made possible.

Reducing humidity in the air handling system and the building spaces during the cooling season will improve indoor air quality by preventing condensation in equipment and reducing the growth and propagation of micro-organisms.

There are two types of desiccant systems: liquid (sorbent) and dry. Liquid desiccant systems remove more moisture from ventilation air than do dry desiccant systems; the air produced by dry desiccant systems, however, is warmer than the air produced by dry desiccant systems.

Liquid desiccant systems commonly use two chambers with air/liquid contact surfaces such as sprayed coils. In the conditioning chamber, ventilation air is dehumidified as the concentrated desiccant absorbs moisture from the air. In the regeneration chamber, building exhaust air is humidified as moisture is transferred from the dilute desiccant to the exhaust air. The exhaust air and/or desiccant is usually heated to promote desiccant regeneration. A desiccant pump, level controls and heat exchanger are typically included in the system.

Dry desiccant systems operate in a manner similar to liquid desiccant systems, but use a desiccant coating on a rotary enthalpy heat exchanger. Dry desiccant systems do not require energy for desiccant regeneration.

Information Sources
HVAC Systems and Equipment, 1996 ASHRAE Handbook, Chapter 22, American Society of Heating, Refrigeration and Air Conditioning Engineers, 1971.
Tullie Circle NE
Atlanta GA 
USA  30329-2305
tel 1 404 636 84003
www.ashrae.org

Contributing Expert
Richard Lay
Enermodal Engineering Ltd.
650 Riverbend Road
Kitchener ON
Canada  N2K 3S2
tel 1 519 743 8777
fax 1 519 743 8778
rlay@enermodal.com

   
Benefits
bullet reduces the energy (electricity) required to dehumidify and cool ventilation air
bullet reduces condensation and the growth of molds
bullet improves the efficiency of refrigeration equipment by operating at a higher evaporator
bullet temperatures and higher COP
bullet permits alternative approaches to air conditioning
bullet reduces the space required for central air-handling equipment and ducts

 

Limitations
bullet higher initial cost
bullet most cost-effective in large buildings with central HVAC equipment
bullet most cost-effective where the cost of regeneration energy (for example, natural gas) is much lower than the cost of refrigeration energy (electricity)

 

Application
Desiccant cooling systems are best suited to health-care buildings where healthy indoor air is critical, and to buildings housing humidity-sensitive processes, for example, microelectronics, photography, printing and archiving.

Desiccant cooling may be practical for office buildings in southern and coastal Canada with central air handling systems; in these buildings, dehumidification can offset the cost of other system components. These systems may also be advantageous when increased ventilation requirements will exceed the capacity of the existing chiller.

Desiccant cooling is not suitable for small unitary systems, except where heat recovery is already going to be provided and the upgrade cost to a desiccant-coated heat wheel is small. The use of desiccant cooling is not practical when latent cooling loads are low, for example, in the Prairies and northern Canada.

Experience
Liquid and dry desiccant dehumidification systems have been used for decades for hospitals and industrial applications, but have not been widely applied to commercial buildings because of high initial cost. Most reported installations are in office buildings and supermarkets in the USA. In Canada, most applications seem to be as rotary heat exchange wheels which are widely used because of benefits during the heating as well as cooling season. However, the "total enthalpy wheel " will not remove 100% of the building latent load.

Cost
Liquid desiccant system, 3700 L/second, controls, no fans, no post cooling: C$20/L/s

Total enthalpy wheel, 5000 L/s, controls, no fans: C$4/L/s

Example Manufacturers
Kathabar
PO Box 791
New Brunswick NJ
USA  08903
tel 1 800 524 1370
fax 1 732 356 0643
www.kathabar.com

HTS Engineering
115 Norfinch Drive
North York ON 
Canada  M3N 1W8
tel 1 416 661 3400
www.htseng.com

Engelhardt/ICC
330 South Warminster Road
Hatboro PA
USA  19040
tel 1 215 625 0700 ext 320

Seasons-4
4500 Industrial Access Road
Douglasville GA 
USA  30134
tel 1 770 489 0716

New Thermal Technologies
12900 Automobile Blvd
Suite 5
Clearwater FL 
USA  33762
tel 1 813 571 1888

Munters/Cargoaire
79 Munroe Street
Amesbury MA 
USA  01913
tel 1 508 388 0600
www.munters.com

 

Lighting, Day lighting & Energy Use

 
 
Day lighting Controls
  
 
Daylighting Controls

 
Definition
Controls that dim or turn off electric lights in response to levels of natural daylight.
 
Building Use
bullet high-rise office
bullet low-rise office
bullet retail
bullet food service
bullet institutional
 
 
Building Type
bullet new
bullet retrofit
 
Development
Status
bullet new technology

Description
Most lighting systems in offices operate at full output regardless of outdoor conditions. On most days, however, day lighting (sunlight through windows) can provide sufficient light levels for most office activities. The results of not dimming electric lights include occupant eye strain (because of excessive light levels) and unnecessarily high electricity use for lighting and air-conditioning (the latter to eliminate heat from lights). Experience has shown that in commercial buildings, the manual operation of lights is unreliable and thus an automatic system is required.

There are two types of day lighting control systems: dimming and switching. Dimming control varies the light output over a wide range to provide the desired light level. Switching controls turn individual lamps off or on as required. In a conventional two-lamp fixture, there are three settings: both lamps off, one lamp on, both lamps on. The same strategy can be used with three- and four-lamp fixtures. Dimming systems require electronic dimmable ballasts and are more expensive than switching systems, however, they achieve the largest savings and do not have the abrupt changes in light level characteristic of switching systems.

In addition to energy savings, electric light dimming systems offer two other advantages over conventional lighting systems. First, conventional lighting systems are typically designed to over-illuminate rooms to account for the 30% drop in lighting output over time. Electric light dimming systems automatically compensate for this reduced output to give a constant light level over time. Second, day lighting controls can be adjusted to give the desired light level for any space. Thus, when floor plans are changed, it is easy to adjust the light levels to meet the lighting needs of each area (provided the system is zoned properly and has sufficient lighting capacity).

A lighting system, windows and HVAC system need to be designed to take maximum advantage of day lighting. The window visible transmission should be high to admit daylight; heavily-tinted windows should be avoided. The building cooling system can be reduced in size when solar gains are at their highest, because the lights will be dimmed to the minimum. Day lighting works best with indirect lighting because with indirect lighting, occupants are less likely to notice changes in electric light output. Conversely, day lighting control does not work well with spot lighting. Maximum energy savings (up to 75%) are achieved when the lighting system is controlled by both day lighting and occupancy sensors.

Information Sources
Tips for Day lighting with Windows

Feasibility Study of Potential for Electrical Energy Savings in Canadian Office Buildings Using Automatic Controls to Dim Perimeter Lights
Natural Resources Canada 1994
580 Booth Street, 13th Floor
Ottawa ON 
Canada K1A 0E4

Field Assessment of Day lighting Systems and Design Tools
Natural Resources Canada
580 Booth Street, 13th Floor
Ottawa ON 
Canada K1A 0E4

Pacific Gas and Electric Company Lighting Articles

Download Day lighting Guide for Canadian Commercial Buildings.

   
Benefits
bullet reduces electricity use
bullet provides a more constant light level
bullet adjusts to provide a range in light levels

 

Limitations
bullet high cost
bullet rapid change in light levels can disturb occupants

 

Application
Dimming systems are best suited to offices, schools and any areas where desk work is being performed. Switching systems can be used in areas with high natural light levels (e.g., atria, entranceways) and where non-critical visual tasks are being performed (e.g., cafeterias, hallways). Of course, neither system is appropriate in non-daylit areas. The lighting control zones and number of sensors need to be carefully designed. At least one sensor is required for each building orientation. The lighting control zone should only be as deep into the building as is effectively daylit; about five meters from windows in conventional office plans. Light shelves can extend the daylit zone further into the building interior.

Experience
There are only a few examples of successful day lighting control systems in Canada. A study of three day lighting systems in Calgary office buildings showed that if not properly designed and commissioned, day lighting systems will either save little energy or be de-activated. On the other hand, day lighting controls in a North York office building reduced perimeter lighting energy by 63%.

Example Buildings
Green on the Grand
Surrey Tax Centre
Mountain Equipment Co-op

Cost
The cost of switching controls is quite modest and should be considered in all applications where changes in light level can be tolerated. Dimming lighting controls are approximately twice the price of switching controls and require electronic dimmable ballasts.

Example Manufacturers
Pass & Seymour
448 North Rivermede Road
Concord ON 
Canada  L4K 3M9
tel 1 905 738 9195 
fax 1 905 738 9721
www.passandseymour.com

Lithonia Lighting Canada
1100 50th Avenue
Lachine PQ 
Canada  H8T 2V3 
tel 1 514 639 3571 
fax 1 514 639 3570
www.lithonia.com

Daylight Controls
5325 N. Commerce Avenue
Moorpark CA
USA  93021
tel 1 805 529 0119
fax 1 805 529 9466
www.daylightcontrols

 

High-efficiency Fluorescent Fixtures
  
 
 
Definition
The Illuminating Engineering Society's definition of luminaries (or fixture) efficiency is "the ratio of lumens emitted by a luminaries to that emitted by the lamps therein."
 
Building Use
bullet high-rise office
bullet low-rise office
bullet high-rise apartment (corridors)
bullet low-rise apartment (corridors)
bullet retail
bullet food service
bullet institutional
bullet arena (support areas)
 
 
Building Type
bullet new
bullet retrofit
 
Development
Status
bullet mature technology

Description
Fluorescent fixtures can be made efficient by virtue of: 

  1. the type of lamps used
     
  2. the material quality and design of the optical components

Manufacturers of fluorescent luminaries continuously strive to design and produce more efficient fixtures. As lamp manufacturers develop new products, these are often quickly adopted by the luminaries manufacturers into smaller and more efficient fixtures. Two recent examples include the use of standard T5 and high output T5 (HOT5) lamps and triple tube compact fluorescent lamps.

When comparing fixtures for a project, efficiency should be one of the last factors to consider. Once a fixture type is chosen, based on its general method of light distribution and aesthetic quality, then a technical data sheet should be obtained. Every manufacturer should be able to provide a technical data sheet or photometric data sheet for each of their luminaries in most every configuration.

The efficiency of a fixture can be called out as a specific line item, or it can be found as the bottom line of the Zonal Lumen Summary on the data sheet. See Figure-1.

If the objective is to compare the efficiency of selected fixtures, then assure the fixtures are equal in most every other way:

  1. general fixture size
     
  2. lensing or louver material, pattern or configuration
     
  3. distribution category

Distribution category can often be considered as narrow, medium or wide. This can apply to recessed down lights, troffers or indirect luminaries. Depending upon the environment, a fixture of one distribution category may be less efficient, but still better suited than a fixture of another distribution category. For example, the objective may be to light a horizontal desktop upon which paper tasks and a computer keyboard will be placed, and to keep light off the vertical plane so that the computer screen is most visible. In this case a fixture with a high efficiency number that distributes light at high angles (hitting the vertical plane) as opposed to straight down would be less appropriate for the job.

Comparing the efficiency of suspended direct/indirect fixtures requires some additional considerations. Factors such as distribution pattern upward, distribution pattern downward, possibility of striations (light streaks) on the ceiling due to poor upper reflector design and number and type of lamps must be reviewed. The very best way to compare fixtures is to conduct a mock-up. Next best method is to obtain a sample of each. Many direct/indirect fixtures are making use of the HOT5 lamp. This lamp, in and of itself, is a very efficient source. However, it may give too much glare in the downward component and may create a "hot spot" (excessive light on the ceiling just above the fixture) when mounted too close to the ceiling (usually less than 18").

   
Benefits
bullet reduces the overall quantity of fixtures in some applications

 

Application
If any component of the luminaire technology is still new, it is best to obtain a sample of the fixture under consideration and to observe it carefully from all angles. Look for potential areas of uncomfortable brightness, distracting dark areas, or uneven distribution of light.

Experience
A recent mock-up using an indirect fixture with a single HOT5 lamp in cross-section allowed fixtures to be spaced farther apart on centre than the traditional two-lamp T8 indirect model. With most other things being equal, the single HOT5 luminaries was almost 15% more efficient than the double T8 luminaries. The former provided energy savings per fixture over the latter as well as requiring fewer fixtures for the whole project.

Cost
A well designed fixture can have a higher initial cost, however, this is not always the case. Consider the total quantity of fixtures required for the project, not just the cost per fixture. 

Information Sources
Illuminating Engineering Society Lighting Handbook, IESNA
120 Wall Street
17th Floor
New York NY
USA  10005
tel 1 212 248 5000
www.iesna.org

Osram Sylvania Ltd.
2001 Drew Road
Mississauga ON
Canada  L5S 1S4
tel 1 905 673 6171
fax 1 905 671 5584
www.sylvania.com

Internet Community for Lighting Professionals

Source for Lighting Specifiers and Buyers

Institute for Research in Construction

Example Manufacturers
Direct distribution luminaries

  Cooper Lighting
Mississauga, ON
tel 1 905 507 4000
  Lithonia Lighting
Conyers, GA
USA  30012
tel 1 770 922 9000
fax 1 770 483 2635
www.lithonia.com


Direct/indirect distribution luminaries

  Ledalite Architectural Products
9087A-198th Street
Langley, BC
Canada  V1M 3BI
tel 1 604 888 6811
fax 1 604 888 2003
www.ledalite.com
  Peerless Lighting
2246 Fifth Street
Berkeley CA
USA  94710
tel 1 510 845 2760
fax 1 510 845 2776
www.peerless-lighting.com

 

Contributing Expert
Jill Klores
Pacific Lightworks Canada/Roeder Design
P.O. Box 4611
Vancouver, B.C.
Canada  V6B 4A1
tel 1 214 528 2300
fax 1 214 521 2300
jill@roederdesign.com

 

Electronic Dimmable Ballasts
  
 


 
Definition
A solid-state ballast that can provide variable light output in response to a signal (from a photosenso, for example).
 
Building Use
bullet high-rise office
bullet low-rise office
bullet low-rise apartment
bullet retail
bullet food service
bullet institutional
bullet arena
 
 
Building Type
bullet new
bullet retrofit
 
Development
Status
bullet mature technology

Description
A fluorescent lamp is a gas discharge light that requires a ballast (either magnetic or electronic) to provide high initial voltage for start-up and to regulate current during operation. Electronic ballasts use solid-state technology and operate at higher frequencies and efficiencies than do magnetic ballasts. Operating lamps with electronic ballasts reduce electricity use by 10 to 15% over magnetic ballasts for the same light output. Electronic ballasts also offer reduced flicker, lower weight, less noise and longer life than do magnetic ballasts.

Electronic ballasts are also available as dimming ballasts. These ballasts allow the light level to be controlled between 1% and 100%. Magnetic ballasts are also available with dimming capability, but they cannot be dimmed below 20% and use more electricity than do electronic ballasts.

Dimmable electronic ballasts can be controlled by photosensors, occupancy sensors and/or a time clock. It is estimated that the combination of photosensor control and dimmable electronic ballasts can reduce annual electricity use by 50% over non-dimming systems. The combination of all three control methods can save approximately 75% of electricity use.

Information Sources

Specifier Reports: Electronic Ballasts, Vol. 2 Num. 3, 1994, Lighting Researcher Center, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute
110 8th Street
Troy NY
USA  12180-3590
tel 1 518 276 8717
fax 1 518 276 4835

Energy Efficient Lighting Product Knowledge Guide
Canadian Electrical Association, 
1155 Metcalfe St.
Suite 1120
Montreal PQ
Canada  H3B 2V6
tel 1 514 866 6121
fax 1 514 866 1880

   
Benefits
bullet reduces electricity use
bullet reduces flicker, weight and noise
bullet generates less heat

 

Limitations
bullet higher cost
bullet possibly shorter lamp and ballast life

 

Application
Electronic dimmable ballasts are best used where the need for electric light is constantly changing (such as the perimeter zones of offices). If only two or three light levels are needed (high level for occupied/low level for unoccupied), it would be better to use conventional electronic ballasts and control the number of lamps that are operated.

Experience
Electronic dimmable ballasts are effective in reducing electricity use when properly installed and operated. The dimming control system, however, should be commissioned to ensure that the lights are dimmed the correct amount in response to the sensor (e.g. photosensor). There is some concern regarding shortened lamp and ballast life, and regarding lamps not starting-up if the ballast is fully dimmed.

Example Buildings
Green on the Grand

Cost
Electronic ballasts are about C$20 each, only slightly more than magnetic ballasts. Electronic dimmable ballasts are approximately C$70 each.

Example Manufacturers
Advance Transformer Co.
O'Hare International Centre
10275 West Higgins Rd.
Rosemont IL
USA  60018
tel 1 800 332 2086
fax 1 847 390 5388
www.advancetransformer.com

Osram Sylvania Ltd.
2001 Drew Rd.
Mississauga ON
Canada  L5S 1S4
tel 1 905 673 6171
fax 1 905 673 1413
www.sylvania.com

 

Occupancy Sensors
  
 

 
Definition
Electrical sensors that detect occupancy and turn lights off or on according to pre-set levels.
 
Building Use
bullet highrise office
bullet lowrise office
bullet highrise apartment
bullet lowrise apartment
bullet retail
bullet food service
bullet institutional
bullet arena
 
 
Building Type
bullet new
bullet retrofit
 
Development
Status
bullet mature technology

Description
In most commercial buildings, electric lights are left on when rooms are unoccupied. While light switches are usually available, occupants cannot be relied upon to turn off lights when rooms are not in use. Occupancy sensors overcome this problem by automatically turning lights off or on as required.

There are two types of occupancy sensors: passive infra-red (PIR) and ultrasonic. PIR sensors sense infra-red heat radiated from the human body (10 micron wave lengths). Because there can be other sources of heat at the same temperature, the sensors respond to changes in position of the source of heat.

Ultrasonic sensors emit an inaudible high frequency tone. Like sonar, the tone bounces off the objects in the room and returns to the sensor. If there is motion, the acoustical response changes and occupancy is sensed. When occupancy is sensed (by either type of sensor), the electric lights are turned on. The lights will stay on until no motion is detected for approximately 15 minutes.

Occupancy sensors have a limited sensing range. Sensors can detect slight hand motion up to 3 m and full body motion up to 10 m. Ultrasonic sensors offer better detection than PIR sensors. In rooms where it is critical that lights do not go off incorrectly, dual technology (PIR and ultrasonic) sensors can be used.

Occupancy sensors can reduce lighting energy use by 30 to 60%, depending on the frequency of room usage. Savings can rise to 75% if the lights are controlled by a combination of occupancy and daylighting controls.

Contributing Expert
John Kokko, P.Eng
Enermodal Engineering Ltd.
650 Riverbend Drive
Kitchener ON
Canada N2K 3S2
tel 1 519 743 8777
fax 1 519 743 8778
jkokko@enermodal.com

   
Benefits
bullet reduces electrical costs for lighting
bullet increases building security

 

Limitations
bullet not suitable for rooms where sensor cannot "see" occupants

 

Application
Occupancy can be used in almost all room types. The type and location of occupancy sensor depends on the application. In individual office spaces lower cost, wall-mounted PIR sensors are typically used. In open offices, ceiling-mounted PIR sensors are used. If, however, there are many partitions and obstructions, ultrasonic sensors should be installed.

Experience
While there were some initial problems with occupancy sensors incorrectly turning lights off or on, the current sensors do not have this problem. Nevertheless, sometimes sensors inadvertently turn off the lights when occupants are sitting very still. This is likely caused by being too far from the sensor or improper sensor sensitivity setting.

Example Buildings
Green on the Grand

Cost
Sensors cost from C$75 to $200 each. The payback on the investment is usually less than two years.

Example Manufacturers
Pass & Seymour
448 North Rivermede Road
Concord ON
Canada  L4K 3M9
tel 1 905 738 9195
fax 1 905 738 9721
www.passandseymour.com
 

 
 

 

HID Electronic Ballasts & Lamps
  
 
HID Electronic Ballasts & Lamps

 
Definition
High Intensity Discharge (HID) lamps produce light by striking an electrical arc across tungsten electrodes housed inside a specially designed inner glass tube. 
 
Building Use
bullet highrise office
bullet institutional
bullet retail
bullet arena
bullet parking garages
bullet food service
bullet warehouse & industrial
bullet residential
 
 
Building Type
bullet new
bullet retrofit
 
Development
Status
bullet prototype (electronic ballasts paired with ac to dc lamps)
bullet new (residential applications and electronic ballasts)
bullet mature (lamps and magnetic ballasts)

Description
High Intensity Discharge (HID) lamps produce light by striking an electrical arc across tungsten electrodes housed inside a specially designed inner glass tube. This tube is filled with both gas and metals. The gas aids in the starting of the lamps and the metals produce the light once they are heated to a point of evaporation. 

HID lamps produce a large quantity of light in a small package in comparison with incandescent and fluorescent sources. HID lighting is typically used when high levels of light are required over large areas and when energy efficiency and/or long life are desired. More recently, however, HID sources, especially metal halide (MH), have been used in small retail and residential environments. 

MH lamps produce a white light, while high pressure sodium (HPS) lamps produce a yellow light. Recent research has shown that the white light produced by MH lamps can allow people to see in greater detail than yellow light, especially in lower level lighting conditions. 

The 400W metal halide lamp, a very common lamp for warehouse, warehouse-retail, arena, atria and exterior applications, has an energy saving option in the 320 W or 360 W standard output or 400-watt high output versions. These options can provide about 15% to 25% energy savings for the same amount of light (320 W and 350 W options), or 10% more light (400 W high output option) for the same energy use.

Like fluorescent lamps, HID lamps require a ballast to start and to maintain their operation. There are numerous ballast types designed for use with HID lamps, each offering different advantages and drawbacks. Recently, electronic ballasts have been used with lower watt HID lamps (primarily 35-100W MH). These ballasts provide an energy savings over magnetic ballasts of 8 - 20%. They also have the advantage of lighter weight, which can be important in some applications, such as track lighting. For further energy savings and light output control, the technology can be used with multi-step or continuous dimming control gear. Note that colour is compromised when HID lamps are dimmed, especially when MH lamps are dimmed below 60% (colour shifts toward blue-green) and when HPS lamps are dimmed below 40% (colour shifts towards yellow). Some lamp manufacturers will limit their warranty if lamps have been dimmed (investigate before purchasing.) Most HID lamps respond to dimming controls more slowly, sometimes taking several minutes to adjust their output. Some smaller lamps will respond immediately.

HID lamps may be clear or phosphor coated on the inside wall of the outer lamp shell. Clear lamps are best when a more precise beam of light is required. Phosphor coated lamps will diffuse the light more and will reduce the colour temperature by about 300°K.

Recently, lamp manufacturers have introduced coloured metal halide lamps. This colouring is achieved by using a single element metal in the arc tube to produce emitted colours such as blue, green, pink and yellow. No colored phosphor or filter is used or required.


Contributing Expert
Jill Klores
Pacific Lightworks Canada/Roeder Design
P.O. Box 4611
Vancouver, BC
Canada  V6B 4A1
tel 1 214 528 2300
fax 1 214 521 2300
jill@roederdesign.com
www.roederdesign.com

   
Benefits
bullet increases energy efficiency in lighting
bullet provides many choices in controls and adjustability. 
bullet slightly higher lamp output
bullet longer lamp life
bullet better lumen maintenance
bullet lighter weight and compact size

 

Application
Most metal halide lamps are designed for a specific burning position; these may be base up, base down, or horizontal burn only. Some lamps are designated for universal burning position, however, there may be lumen output sacrifices associated with this type. 

There are several arc tube designs for MH technology. These are formed, pinched and shaped. Recent experience has shown that formed arc tubes can allow universal burning positions without compromise to lamp output. This design can also have the benefit of better colour uniformity (due to uniform wall thickness providing more consistent halide cooling rates), shorter lamp warm up and re-strike periods (due to higher pressure gas fill), longer life (due to decreased electrode damage), colder starting temperatures (down to 40oC), and better lumen maintenance (light output over time - due to all above characteristics).
 

Cost
It is difficult to compare the cost of an HID lighting system to another type of system (fluorescent or incandescent), as the performance and characteristic differences are so great. When comparing energy saving lamps or high-output lamps to standard output lamps, initial cost may be higher (however, large quantities may negate cost difference) but energy savings is approximately 15% to 25% for the energy saving lamps and fewer fixtures may be required with the high-output lamps. 

Currently, HID electronic ballasts are more than double the cost of their magnetic counterparts. However, manufacturers are presently introducing prototype electronic ballast/lamp systems that are more comparable to the magnetic systems. 

Information Sources
Illuminating Engineering Society lighting Handbook, IESNA
120 Wall Street, 17th Floor
New York NY 
USA 10005
tel 1 212 248 5000
www.iesna.org

Internet Community for Lighting Professionals

Source for Lighting Specifiers and Buyers

Microsun Technologies (residential HID luminaires)
tel 1 888 526 0033
www.microsun.com

Example Manufacturers
Venture Lighting
32000 Aurora Road
Solon OH
USA  44139
tel 1 800 451 2606
fax 1 440 349 7771
www.venturelighting.com

Philips Electronics Ltd.
601 Milner Avenue
Scarborough ON
Canada M1B 1M8 
tel 1 416 292 5161
fax 1 416 292 2057
www.philips.com

Osram/Sylvania
2001 Drew Road
Mississauga ON
Canada L5S 1S4
tel 1 905 673 6171
fax 1 905 673 5584
www.sylvania.com

Aromat Canada Inc.
109 Woodbine Downs Blvd., Unit 9
Etobicoke ON
Canada  M9W 6Y1
tel 1 800 4 AROMAT
fax 1 416 674 4933 www.aromat.com

 

Energy Efficient Office Equipment
  
 

 
Definition
Computers, printers, photocopiers and fax machines equipped with power management settings; printers and photocopiers capable of double-sided printing.
 
Building Use
bullet highrise office
bullet lowrise office
bullet highrise apartment
bullet lowrise apartment
bullet retail
bullet food service
bullet institutional
bullet arena
 
 
Building Type
bullet new
bullet retrofit
 
Development
Status
bullet mature technology

Description
Computers
Among office equipment, computers are the largest consumers of energy. New versions of computers are now equipped with power management capabilities. These settings allow a computer to become more energy-efficient by powering down to about 15% of their maximum power usage when they are not in use. 

It is important to note that this powering-down capability does not refer to screen savers. Screen savers are used to prevent an image from being permanently burnt into the screen, and are actually heavy users of computer power. 

Some or all hardware found in recently produced computers is now comprised of 3.3-volt components, which use 40% to 50% less energy than 5.0-volt systems found in older equipment.

Printers
Printers consume 30-40% of their peak power requirement even when idling, and this outweighs consumption during the printing process if left idling for long periods of time. Energy-efficient printers power down 15-45 W or less depending on model specifications, which reduces energy use by 50% while idling. 

Printers that allow double-sided printing reduces energy use since much more energy is consumed in paper production than in printing. A further reduction in energy use would be the use of an inkjet instead of a laser printer. Inkjet printers are inexpensive, have low energy consumption, and allow for the reuse of paper, which saves on costs and reduces environmental impacts.

Photocopiers
Heat and pressure fusing is the most common photocopying technology and is also the most energy-consuming. Most heat and pressure fusing machines are now equipped with an energy-saver feature that can save energy consumption in idling mode by at least 50%. 

Photocopiers rated by the US Energy Star program power down to low-power after 15 minutes of non-usage, and to off-mode (5-20 W) after 120 minutes without use. 

Fax Machines
Conventional fax machines use a lot of energy in both printing and idling modes. Energy-efficient fax machines power down to 15-45 W or less, depending on model specifications. Thermal andl laser fax machines are now commonly used in industry. Inkjet printing is better than laser printing in terms of energy efficiency, but is slower.

Information Sources
US Department of Energy Energy Star Program

ACEEE Publications on Office Equipment

   
Benefits
Computers
bullet reduces operating cost and energy consumption
bullet occasionally increases mobility (for example, laptop computers)
Printers, Photocopiers, and Fax Machines
bullet reduces paper and printing costs
bullet reduces filing space
bullet reduces energy consumption

 

Limitations
bullet power management settings have to be set properly
bullet equipment uses more energy when left on rather than turned off when not in use, regardless of energy efficiency enhancements
bullet electricity consumption increases with additional components
bullet laser printers consume more energy than do conventional inkjet or dot matrix printers
bullet thermal fax machines use less energy than laser fax machines
bullet laser fax machines print on regular paper instead of thermal paper

Experience
Computers and Printers
Most new computers and printers now come equipped with power management settings and reduced energy costs; energy-efficient computers are used in all types of industries, businesses and residences.

Photocopiers
The American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) provides ratings of photocopiers for energy consumption. These power ratings provide an accurate means of comparing energy consumption, since ASTM bases ratings on standardized testing methods.

Fax Machines
The initial cost of a thermal fax machine is much less than a plain paper fax, but the long-term operating costs are usually greater. Thermal paper is non-recyclable, and messages often get recopied onto regular paper. However inkjet fax machines are still much cheaper than both thermal or laser machines and can reuse paper. Look for an energy saver feature like a standby mode, which offers low energy consumption.

Application
Computers
Energy-efficient computers are well suited to any application, especially where computers are left idling for long periods of time without use. Many computers can perform similar functions, yet they vary significantly in terms of energy efficiency. The most energy-efficient computers are laptop computers, which use 10% or less power to operate than a regular PC and have low power use settings. Laptops are designed with liquid crystal displays (LCDs), and these consume far less energy than regular PC monitors comprised of cathode ray tubes (CRTs).

Printers
Energy-efficient printers are best suited for any application involving printers on a continual basis. Energy efficiencies more than make up for minor inconveniences of time delay for such things as printer warm-up and actual printing.

Photocopiers
Energy-efficient photocopiers are best suited for any application involving large quantities of copying on a continual basis.

Fax Machines
Energy efficient fax machines are best suited for any application that uses them on a regular basis and/or has them idling for long periods of time.

Cost
A new brand-name computer can range anywhere between C$2000-$4000 on average.

A typical new brand name printer can range anywhere between C$150-$7000, depending on type and specifications.

A photocopier can range anywhere from C$400-$6000 and up, depending on type and specifications.

A fax machine can range anywhere from C$150-$1000 and up, depending on type and specifications.

Example Manufacturers
Computers
Dell Computer Corp.
One Dell Way
Round Rock TX
USA  78682
tel 1 800 915 3355
www.dell.com

Printers
Lexmark International, Inc.
740 W. New Circle Rd.
Lexington, KY
USA  40550
tel 1 800 LEXMARK
www.lexmark.com

Photocopiers & Fax Machines
Canon USA, Inc.
One Canon Plaza
Lake Success, NY
USA 11042-1198
fax 516-328-4669
www.canon.com

Water Usage

 
Ultra-low-flush Toilets
  
 

 
Definition
Low-flush toilets are designed to use six litres of water per flush, significantly less water than conventional toilets use.
 
Building Use
bullet highrise office
bullet lowrise office
bullet highrise apartment
bullet lowrise apartment
bullet retail
bullet food service
bullet institutional
bullet arena
 
 
Building Type
bullet new
bullet retrofit
 
Development
Status
bullet mature technology

Description
Approximately 30 to 40% of water used inside residential buildings is used for toilet flushing. Conventional toilets consume 23 L of water per flush. Six-litre toilets consume six litres of water per flush. Since toilets last approximately 15 to 20 years, the water and dollar savings over the lifetime of the fixture are substantial. In apartment buildings, about a 40% reduction in water use can be achieved through the use of 6-L toilets.

Although a 6-L toilet looks like a conventional toilet, it has several unique features. Most 6-L toilets use gravity to speed the course of water through the bowl and trap. The rim wash comes through an open slot rather than small holes. The bowl may have steep sides and a narrow trap opening. Six-litre flush toilets generally have a smaller pool or "water spot" than that in conventional toilets.

Six-litre toilets should contain the CSA or Warnock Hersey label. This ensures that the toilet has passed primary performance and maintenance tests. Six-litre toilets are available in both residential and special needs styles.

Information Sources
"National Action Plan to Encourage Municipal Water Use Efficiency" 
Canadian Council of Ministers of the Environment
123 Main St., Suite 360
Winnipeg MB
Canada R3C 1A3
tel 1-204-948-2090
www.ccme.ca

Water Wiser: The Water Efficiency Clearinghouse
tel 1 800 926 7337
fax 1 303 347 0804
www.waterwiser.org

Contributing Expert
Deborah Walker
Region of Waterloo
Manager, Water Efficiency
150 Frederick Street, 7th Floor
Kitchener ON
Canada N2G 4J3
tel: 1 519 575 4503
fax: 1 519 575 4452
wdeborah@region.waterloo.on.ca

   
Benefits
bullet reduces water requirements in single family residences by about 20% and in multi-residential units by about 40%

 

Limitations
bullet some models may require more frequent cleaning with a toilet brush
bullet there may be problem with clogging drains in unusual installations, for example, a solitary half-bathroom that drains into a very long horizontal plumbing

 

Application
Six-litre toilets can be used in most settings. Their greatest potential lies in the replacement market and in large commercial and institutional users. On January 1, 1996, the Ontario Plumbing Code was amended to require the installation of 6-L toilets in all new residential buildings.

Experience
European countries have used these toilets for many years, and the building codes in many European countries require the use of 6-L toilets. It is only in the last 6 years that 6-L toilets have become readily available to North Americans.

Six-litre toilet replacement programs are an important component of long-term water conservation strategies in numerous cities and municipalities across North America. Major initiatives have begun in the following locations: The Regional Municipality of Waterloo, Kitchener, Ontario; Barrie, Ontario; The Regional Municipality of Durham, Whitby, Ontario; Windsor, Ontario; Tampa, Florida; Los Angeles, California; El Paso, Texas; San Diego, California

Some commercial and industrial users also have replacement programs. Among these are major hotel chains in Canada and the USA, universities, and retirement/nursing homes and other commercial operations.

Cost
Although cost varies by make and model, the price of 6-litre toilet is approximately the same price as a conventional toilet. Toilets certified by CSA or Warnock Hersey cost approximately C$150 to $500 depending on the make, model and colour choices.

Example Manufacturers
American Standard
1 Centennial Avenue #101
Piscataway NJ
USA 08854
tel 1 732 980 3000
fax 1 732 980 6162
www.americanstandard.ca

Crane Plumbing
1235 Hartrey Avenue
Evanston IL 
USA 60202
tel 1 847 864 9777
fax 1 847 864 7652
www.craneplumbing.com

Kohler Ltd.
110 Woodbine Downs Blvd.
Unit 12
Etobicoke ON
Canada M9W 6Y1
tel 1 416 798 9311
fax 1 416 798 9181
www.kohlerco.com

Thermal Conductivity

 
Mineral-wool Based EIFS
  
 


 
Definition
An exterior cladding system comprised of mineral-wool insulation and a sprayed coating.
 
Building Use
bullet highrise office
bullet lowrise office
bullet highrise apartment
bullet lowrise apartment
bullet retail
bullet food service
bullet institutional
bullet arena
 
 
Building Type
bullet new
bullet retrofit
 
Development
Status
bullet new technology

Description
EIFS (exterior insulation and finishing system) is a building cladding that offers improved thermal and moisture performance over conventional cladding systems. EIFS consists of four layers. These are, from exterior to interior, a spray-applied acrylic and stone finish, a fibreglass reinforcing mesh, insulation, and an adhesive that attaches the cladding system to the building. Most EIFS systems use expanded polystyrene as the insulation.

EIFS systems have several advantages over other cladding systems. First, the system covers the entire building wall (except windows and doors). Thus, EIFS provides an insulation layer over potential thermal bridges such as wall studs and columns and floor-wall junctions. Second, because the entire exterior wall is covered, building airtightness is improved. Third, because insulation is placed on the building exterior, the building structure is kept warm; this minimizes thermal expansion and contraction. Finally, if properly installed, the system avoids a build-up of moisture in the building cladding. (In brick veneer systems, moisture build-up can cause spawling and cracking of the brick.)

Fire code regulations restrict the use of polystyrene insulation to lowrise buildings. One EIFS system utilizes mineral wool as the insulation layer to overcome this limitation; a mineral-wool based EIFS can be used for buildings of any height. A further advantage of mineral wool insulation is that wall system pressure differences can be even out because the air can travel along the insulation layer.

Information Sources
Exterior Insulation Finish Systems Industry Members Association

   
Benefits
bullet increases insulation levels
bullet minimizes thermal bridging
bullet reduces air leakage
bullet suits many building types

 

Limitations
bullet exterior walls must be well sealed to prevent moisture damage

 

Application
It is important that a EIFS cladding system be used as a continuous covering, and that the cladding be applied so as to prevent the entrance of moisture.

Mineral-wool based EIFS is particularly well suited to highrise residential and commercial buildings because this type of cladding provides greater fire resistance and superior thermal performance is not found in many other cladding systems.

Experience
There are many successful applications of EIFS in all climate types. The system can be applied to any vertical surface in both new and retrofit installations. While there have been some problems with moisture accumulation within the cladding, these problems are generally attributed to improper installation.

Cost
EIFS systems cost about C$100/m2 (installed). This cost is competitive with steel stud and brick veneer systems, and is less expensive than curtainwall systems.

Example Manufacturers
STO Corporation
3800 Camp Creek Parkway
Building 1400, Suite 120
Atlanta GA
USA  30331
tel 1 800 221 2397
www.stocorp.com

 

Inert Gas Window Fills
  
 


 
Definition
The use of a low-conductivity inert gas instead of air in window glazing cavities in order to reduce heat transmission through the window.
 
Building Use
bullet highrise office
bullet lowrise office
bullet highrise apartment
bullet lowrise apartment
bullet retail
bullet food service
bullet institutional
bullet arena
 
 
Building Type
bullet new
bullet retrofit
 
Development
Status
bullet mature technology

Description
Most windows have a sealed glazing unit: two or more lites of glass that are sealed around the perimeter to prevent the transfer of air and moisture through the window cavity. The gas which fills the inter-glazing cavity affects the heat transfer through the assembly but has almost no effect on the solar heat gain or the visible light transmission.

Air, of course, is the most common cavity fill gas, but the use of an inert gas (typically argon or krypton) can significantly reduce window heat transfer. Krypton and argon are colourless, odourless and non-toxic. Argon is the most commonly-used fill gas because it offers good thermal performance at low cost. Krypton is more effective at reducing heat loss, but is roughly 200 times more expensive than argon per unit volume. Because krypton works best at smaller pane spacings (8 mm), it is often used in triple and quadruple-glazed windows to minimize the overall thickness of the unit. Other types of gases are used (for example, sulphur hexafluoride, carbon dioxide) to reduce sound transmission, but these gases do not offer the improved thermal performance of the inert gases.

Several different techniques are used to fill glazing cavities, but all techniques result in a mixture of the fill gas and air. A recently approved Canadian General Standards Board standard requires units to achieve a 90% fill gas concentration. This concentration will gradually diffuse over time; this diffusion is estimated at 0.5 to 1% per year. Thus, after 20 years the fill gas concentration may have dropped to 70 to 80%; this still gives 70 to 80% of the energy benefits of inert gas fills over conventional windows.

Contributing Expert
Stephen Carpenter, P.Eng
Enermodal Engineering Ltd.
650 Riverbend Drive
Kitchener ON
Canada  N2K 3S2
tel 1 519 743 8777
fax 1 519 743 8778
scarpenter@enermodal.com

   
Benefits
bullet reduces wintertime heat loss
bullet reduces summertime conduction heat gain

 

Limitations
bullet can only be used in sealed glazing units

 

Application
The low cost and good performance of inert gas fills should make their use mandatory whenever a low-e coating is used in a glazing unit. The low-e coating reduces radiative heat loss and the inert gas fill reduces convective heat loss, so that the two technologies used in combination are an effective barrier to heat loss. The use of inert gas fills without a low-e coating is only marginally effective in reducing heat loss.

Experience
Although inert gas fills are quite common in residential windows, their use in commercial windows is uncommon because they are rarely specified by architects. There are, however, many applications that have demonstrated the long term suitability of this technology.

Example Buildings
Green on the Grand
Condominium at 77 Governors Road

Cost
The cost of this technology is about C$3 to $5/m2 of window.

Example Manufacturers
Almost all window and sealed glazing unit manufacturers offer inert gas fills as an option.

Information Sources
Energy-Efficient Residential and Commercial Window Reference Guide, Canadian Electrical Association
1 Westmount Square
Suite 1600
Montreal PQ
Canada  H3Z 2P9
tel 1 514 937 6181
fax 1 514 937 6498

Efficient Windows Collaborative

 


Warm-edge Windows
  
 
Warm-edge Windows
 
Definition
A low-conductivity material used to separate the lites of glass in a sealed glazing unit.
 
Building Use
bullet highrise office
bullet lowrise office
bullet highrise apartment
bullet lowrise apartment
bullet retail
bullet food service
bullet institutional
bullet arena
 
 
Building Type
bullet new
bullet retrofit
 
Development
Status
bullet new technology

Description
Most windows have a sealed glazing unit: two or more lites of glass that are sealed around the perimeter. An edge-spacer is used around the perimeter to separate the lites of glass and to prevent transfer of air and moisture in and out of the inter-glass cavity. Typical practice has been the use of an aluminum edge-spacer. The high conductivity of aluminum causes high heat loss and cold interior temperatures in the edge-of-glass region during the winter. The result is a band of condensation or frost at the bottom of the glazing unit.

Warm-edge spacers either incorporate a thermal break in the spacer assembly or are constructed from a low-conductivity material. There are many designs of warm-edge spacers, but the most effective designs are constructed from polymers with little or no metal content. Besides being a barrier to heat flow, the spacer assembly must prevent moisture from diffusing into the sealed cavity. Sealed units used in Canada should be tested to Canadian General Standards Board Standard 12.8 and certified by the Insulating Glass Manufacturers Association of Canada.

Contributing Expert
Stephen Carpenter, P.Eng
Enermodal Engineering Ltd.
650 Riverbend Drive
Kitchener ON
Canada  N2K 3S2
tel 1 519 743 8777
fax 1 519 743 8778
scarpenter@enermodal.com
www.enermodal.com

   
Benefits
bullet reduces wintertime heat loss
bullet reduces summertime solar heat gain
bullet reduces condensation at the bottom of glazing units
bullet reduces thermal stress on glazing unit and therefore results in less breakage

 

Limitations
bullet higher cost             

 

Application
The low cost and good performance of warm-edge spacers makes this technology suitable for all window systems and should be considered mandatory whenever low-e coatings and inert gas fills are used. If warm-edge technology is not used with low-e, inert gas filled windows, much of the benefit of these technologies is lost because heat is conducted along the glass and across the edge spacer.

Experience
Warm-edge spacers are becoming increasing popular for commercial windows. The durability of these edge-seals has been proven over the last few years and in fact some manufacturers note reduced seal failures because of the reduced thermal stress on the glazing.

Cost
The cost of this technology is about C$3 to $5/m2 of window.

Example Manufacturers
Almost all window and sealed glazing unit manufacturers offer inert gas fills as an option.

Example Buildings
Green on the Grand
Dundas Condominium

Information Sources
Energy-Efficient Residential and Commercial Window Reference Guide, Canadian Electrical Association
1 Westmount Square
Suite 1600
Montreal PQ
Canada  H3Z 2P9
tel 1 514 937 6181
fax 1 514 937 6498

Efficient Windows Collaborative

 

Spectrally-selective Glazings
  
 


 
Definition
A tinted or coated glazing that has solar/optical properties which vary across the solar spectrum. Typically these glazings have high transmission of visible light but low transmission of solar gains.
 
Building Use
bullet highrise office
bullet lowrise office
bullet retail
bullet food service
bullet institutional
 
 
Building Type
bullet new
bullet retrofit
 
Development
Status
bullet mature technology   

Description
Solar radiation has three components: ultra-violet, visible and infra-red. Approximately 50% of the sun's energy occurs outside of the visible portion of the spectrum, giving heat but no light. Spectrally-selective glazings transmit a high proportion of the visible solar radiation (sunlight), but screen out up to 80% of the infra-red radiation. This results in a low transmission of radiant heat from the sun, and reduces the need to cool building interiors.

Conventional blue- and green-tinted glazings and some low-emissivity coatings are spectrally-selective to a small degree. The new generation of spectrally selective glazings are designed to exaggerate the difference between the visible and infra-red portions of the spectrum, and are thus highly efficient in blocking out infra-red radiation. Because of this design, the glazings often have a slight blue or green appearance; however, they are not as deeply coloured as conventional tinted glazings because they transmit visible light relatively evenly over the visible spectrum.

Spectrally-selective glazing is usually used as the outboard lite of a sealed glass unit in order that any absorbed solar gains are lost to the outdoors. Depending on the size and design of the glazing unit, the spectrally-selective glazing may have to be tempered.

The tints used to create the spectrally-selective effect do not affect the heat loss or U-value of the window. A low-emissivity coating can be added to either the spectrally- selective glazing or the inboard glazing to improve thermal performance.

A common measure of the performance of spectrally-selective glazing units is the light-to-solar ratio (LSR). This is the ratio of visible light transmission divided by the solar heat gain coefficient for the glazing system. The highest possible ratio is approximately 2.0. Clear glazing units have a value close to 1.0, while a good spectrally-selective glazing system would have a value greater than 1.7.

Contributing Expert
Stephen Carpenter, P.Eng
Enermodal Engineering Ltd.
650 Riverbend Road
Kitchener ON
Canada  N2K 3S2
tel 1 519 743 8777
fax 1 519 743 8778
scarpenter@enermodal.com

   
Benefits
bullet lowers cooling loads
bullet increases natural lighting

 

Limitations
bullet higher cost
bullet low wintertime solar heat gains

 

Application
Spectrally-selective glazings are best suited to buildings that require high light levels and have a long cooling season. These buildings would include office buildings, fast-food restaurants and atriums. The lighting systems should be controlled by an electric light dimming system (see Daylighting Controls) in order to take advantage of the high light transmission provided by the glazings. Highrise and lowrise residential buildings in cool climates are not well suited to spectrally-selective glazings because of the large reduction in winter solar heat gain.

Experience
Many buildings use spectrally-selective glazings. Because the glazing is part of the window, there are no installation or commissioning issues beyond normal practice. Occupants appreciate the clear view and natural light, and the ability to sit in direct sunlight without becoming uncomfortably warm. A shading or blind system is, however, required to control glare.

Example Buildings
Green on the Grand

Example Manufacturers
Most glass manufacturers produce some version of spectrally-selective glass.

PPG Canada Inc.
834 Caledonia Road
Toronto ON
Canada  M6B 3X9
tel 1 416 789 3331
www.ppgaf.com

Libbey Owens Ford
1701 East Broadway
Toledo OH 
USA  43605
tel 1 419 247 4203
www.lof.com

Cardinal IG
7115 West Lake Street
Minneapolis MN
USA  55426
tel 1 612 929 0317
www.mntc.net

Information Sources
The VISION computer program can be used to determine the light-to-solar gain ratio and other solar/optical properties of almost any glazing system.

FRAMEplus
This software determines the solar optical properties of almost any window system.

Energy-Efficient Residential and Commercial Window Reference Guide, Canadian Electrical Association
1 Westmount Square
Suite 1600
Montreal PQ
Canada  H3Z 2P9
tel 1 514 937 6181
fax 1 514 937 6498
Energy Efficient Windows Collaborative

Download Daylighting Guide for Canadian Commercial Buildings.

 

Low-conductivity Window Frames
  
 


 
Definition
A window or curtain-wall framing system constructed from materials with low thermal conductivity in order to reduce heat loss.
 
Building Use
bullet highrise office
bullet lowrise office
bullet highrise apartment
bullet lowrise apartment
bullet retail
bullet food service
bullet institutional
bullet arena
 
 
Building Type
bullet new
bullet retrofit
 
Development
Status
bullet mature technology

Description
Although frames, sash and mullion assemblies comprise only 10% to 25% of the window area in commercial buildings, they can account for up to half of the window heat loss and can be the prime site for the formation of condensation. 

Two techniques are used to improve the performance of window frames. First, in metal frames, a wide strip of low-conductivity material, referred to as a thermal break, is used to separate the inner and outer halves of the frame. Most commercial windows incorporate a thermal break, however, the thermal break is only 3 mm to 12 mm wide. Improved metal frames have thermal breaks between 12 mm and 75 mm wide and are made from vinyl (instead of liquid urethane or nylon).

The second technique is to construct the frame from a low-conductivity material such as wood or vinyl. Durability, maintenance and/or fire concerns usually limit the use of these framing materials in commercial buildings. An alternative framing material is fibreglass (glass reinforced polyester); fibreglass is stronger than vinyl and has lower maintenance requirements than wood. The cavities in the fibreglass frame can be filled with foam insulation for even better thermal performance. Because fibreglass is considered a combustible material, there are limits to the size and range of applications in which fibreglass frames may be used.

The thermal performance of window systems is defined for Canada in Canadian Standards Association Standard A440.2. An energy-efficient window system would have a total window heat loss coefficient of under 2.0 W/m2K.

Information Sources
Energy-Efficient Residential and Commercial Window Reference Guide, Canadian Electrical Association
1 Westmount Square
Suite 1600
Montreal PQ
Canada  H3Z 2P9
tel 1 514 937 6181
fax 1 514 937 6498

Efficient Windows Collaborative

Contributing Expert
Stephen Carpenter, P.Eng
Enermodal Engineering Ltd.
650 Riverbend Drive
Kitchener ON
Canada  N2K 3S2
tel 1 519 743 8777
fax 1 519 743 8778
scarpenter@enermodal.com

   
Benefits
bullet reduces wintertime heat loss
bullet reduces summertime solar heat gain
bullet reduces risk of interior condensation

 

Limitations
bullet higher cost
bullet difficulties in complying with fire codes

 

Application
The use of low-conductivity window frames will reduce energy use in all types of buildings. Apartment buildings and commercial buildings with punched windows can use frames of low-conductivity materials. In Canada, fire code requirements state that the area of windows with combustible framing materials (e.g., fibreglass) be less than 40% of the building wall area, and that windows must be separated by non-combustible materials. Metal frame windows with a wide thermal break are required for curtain wall construction or buildings with large glazed areas.

Experience
Many commercial buildings are constructed using low conductivity window frames. The installation and commissioning of these windows are no different than for conventional windows. The reduced risk of condensation has made low-conductivity frames particularly beneficial where humidity control is important, such as in hospitals and museums. A warm-edge spacer should also be used to minimize condensation.

Example Buildings
Green on the Grand
Condominium at 77 Governors Road

Cost
The increased cost of low-conductivity frames is in the range of C$30 to $100/m2 of window.

Example Manufacturers
Accurate Dorwin
660 Nairn Avenue
Winnipeg MB
Canada  R2L 0Y5
tel 1 204 663 0020
fax 1 888 982 4640
www.accuratedorwin.com

Thermotech Windows Ltd.
109-42 Antares Drive
Nepean ON
Canada  K2E 7Y4
tel 1 613 225 1101
fax 1 613 225 4630
www.thermotechwindows.com

Kawneer
1051 Ellesmere Road
Scarborough ON
Canada  M1P 2X1
tel 1 416 755 7751
www.kawneer.com

Visionwall
#110, 14904-123 Avenue
Edmonton AB
Canada  T5V 1B4
tel 1 780 451 4000
fax 1 780 451 4745
www.visionwall.com

 

 
 

http://www.advancedbuildings.org/_frames/fr_cs_gog.htm Location of information on this site.