Tutorial: Microchip PIC16F877 Microcontroller

 

Table of Contents

 

1. Introduction

1.1  What is a Microcontroller?

1.2  Why are Microcontrollers used?

2        Getting started

2.1  Parts list and vendors

2.2  Connecting the equipment

3        PIC16fF877 Microcontroller

3.1  Flash PIC development board

3.2  CCS PIC-C compiler

3.3  In Circuit Debugger/Programmer (ICD-S)

3.4  Embedded C Programming and the Microchip PIC

4        Experiments on PIC16F877

4.1  LED 

4.2  Dip Switch

4.3  ADC Temperature Measurement

4.4  Open Loop and Closed Loop Temperature Control

5        Where do we go from here?

 

 

1.      Introduction

This tutorial is to introduce the microcontroller technolgy the capabilities and the specifications of a commonly used Microcontroller Microchip PIC16F877 and describe the experiments conducted using the Development board Flash PIC development board which accomodates this microcontroller.

 

1.1.   What is a microcontroller?

A microcontroller is a compact standalone computer, optimized for control applications. Entire processor, memory and the I/O interfaces are located on a single piece of silicon so, it takes less time to read and write to extrernal devices.

1.2.   Why are microcontrollers used?

Following are the reasons why microcontrollers are incorporated in control systems:

  1. Cost: Microcontrollers with the supplemantary circuit components are much cheaper than a computer with an analog and digital I/O
  2. Size and Weight: Microcontrollers are compact and light compared to computers
  3. Simple applications: If the application requires very few number of I/O and the code is relatively small, which do not require extended amount of memory and a simple LCD display is sufficient as a user interface, a microcontroller would be suitable for this application.
  4. Reliability: Since the architecture is much simpler than a computer it is less likely to fail.
  5. Speed:  All the components on the microcontroller are located on a singe piece of silicon. Hence, the applications run much faster than it does on a computer.

 

2.      Getting Started

2.1.   Parts list:

 

The parts list and the vendor list is given in Table-2.1.1

 

Description

  Vendor

Part No.

Price

Qty.

FlashPIC-Development Board

PRLLC

FlashPIC-Dev

45.00$

1

CCS ICD-S debugger/

programmer

PRLLC

ICD-S

75.00$

1

Embedded C Programming and the Microchip PIC

Richard H. Barnett,

Larry D. O’Cull,

Sarah A. Cox

ISBN: 1401837484

 Amazon.com

N/A

57.70$

1

12VDC adapter

Radioshack

273-1776

16.99$

1

8 position dip switch

Jameco

38842

0.89$

1

Multipurpose PC Board

Radioshack

276-150

$1.69

1

LM35CZ Linear Series

Jameco

107107

$5.79

1

Plastic Sphere

Bubblegum machine

 

 

 

DAC-0832 8 bit DAC

Jameco

128186

3.95

1

LF353 Op-Amp

Jameco

22939

$.39

1

10Kohm Resistor

Radioshack

271-1335

$.99

1

20Kohm Resistor

Radioshack

271-0265

$.99

2

10ohm 10W Resistor

Radioshack

271-132

$1.69

1

TIP31 Power Transistor

Jameco

33048

$.49

1

0.01uF Capacitor

Radioshack

272-1051

$1.19

1

1N4004 Diode

Radioshack

276-1103

$.79

1

100 ohm resistor

Radioshack

271-1311

$.99

1

Technie Toyz 12V PC Fan

Compusa

MD-TTF-8025A-2B

$10.99

1

9V battery

Radioshack

23-875

$3.29

1

6-Ft. Serial RS-232C Cable

Radio Shack

26-117

$13.49

1

1x40 pin header

Jameco

103270

0.75$

1

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Note: It is assumed that the user has the following common electrical equipment: 1x8 pin ribbon cable, alligator clips, soldering iron and solder.

 

 

2.2.   Connecting the equipment

a. Powering up the PIC Development Board

The PIC16F877 chip has to be powered at all times when its being programmed and running an application.

  1. Cut the connector off the DC end of the 12VDC adapter and strip the wire ends.
  2. Determine the + and – wire leads using a voltmeter.
  3. Apply the 12VDC to the board by connecting the 12VDC adapter to + and – pins of J2 of Flash PIC Development Board. See Figure2.2-1

Caution: Make sure you wire the – and + ends of the adapter of the to the right pins of Jumper 2. Do not plug the adapter to 110V/AC outlet before you wire the power to the board. In order to avoid cheking the leads with a voltmeter everytime, its always a good practice to label the leads for future reference.

Figure-2.2-1 12VDC Power connection J2

 

  1. Plug the adapter to the 110V/AC outlet.
  2. Observe the green LED D9 illuminating and rest of the LEDs flashing in order.

 

b.Connecting the Flash PIC Development Board to a PC through ICD-S:

After we put power on the FlashPIC development board, now we are ready to program the PIC16F877 chip.

1.      Connect the ICD-S to the computer using the RS-232 cable, which came with the ICD-S.

2.      Conncect the ICD-S to the developmet board using the phone jack. (See Figure2.2-2)

Figure2.2-2 Connecting the ICD-S, PC, and the FlashPIC-Development Board

c. Coding,Compiling and Transfering the .hex files to the chip

 Now that we have our hardware setup, we are ready to write the code and transfer the .hex files to the PIC16F877.

  1. Install the CCS compiler demo version, which came with the reference book ”Embedded C Programming and the Microchip PIC” to your computer
  2. Insall the ICD software which came with the ICD-S unit.
  3. Start the CCS compiler.
  4. Go to menu path: Options>Debugger/Programmer
  5. Change the to the path of Icd.exe. (See Figure2.2-3)This would enable starting the ICD-S software via toolbar button.

 

Figure-2.2-3 Device Debugger/Programmer Options Menu

  1. The software setup is complete. We can type the source code and compile it and transfer the file to the PIC chip as illustrated in Figure2.0-3. After single clicking the “compile” command button on the toolbar and generating the .hex file, we can single click the “program chip” command button. These coomand buttons are illustrated in Figure 2.2-4.

Figure2.2-4 The CCS Compiler

  1. After the “program chip” command button is pressed the ICD V2.7 program is initiated. First we check the RS-232 communications, the ICD-S and the PIC16F877 by using the following command buttons respectively: “Check COMM”, “Test ICD”, “Test Target”. If all of them check to be OK, now we can browse and transfer the .hex file to the chip by using “Download to target Command button”. After the .hex file is transferred, now we can run the software and test its functionality by clicking on “Run Program” command button. (Figure2.2-4)
  2. Since the software is tested now the ICD-S can be disconnected and the Development board can be powered up and the .hex file can be run without being connected to the computer.

Figure2.2-5 ICD Control Program

 

3.      PIC16F877 Microcontroller

                         In this section, properties of PIC16F877 microcontroller,CCS compiler, ICD-S, the reference book “Embedded C programming and the microchip PIC” are briefly explained to give a general idea; it may seem confusing for a first time reader who is not familiar to microcontrollers technology or C programming. However, as the funtionality of the components such as timers, A/D converters, I/O Ports are explained in detail in Section 3 as they are being used in the experiments, the fundemental concepts would be better understood and, the reader can flashback to this section to view the schematics and the specifications.

 

                         PIC16F877 is one of the most commonly used microcontroller especially in automotive, industrial, appliances and consumer applications. In Figure –1, the block diagram of the PIC16F877 is illustrated.  

The core features of PIC16F877 are:

High performance RISC CPU

• Only 35 single word instructions to learn

• All single cycle instructions except for program

branches which are two cycle

• Operating speed: DC - 20 MHz clock input

DC - 200 ns instruction cycle

• Up to 8K x 14 words of FLASH Program Memory,

Up to 368 x 8 bytes of Data Memory (RAM)

Up to 256 x 8 bytes of EEPROM Data Memory

• Pinout compatible to the PIC16C73B/74B/76/77

• Interrupt capability (up to 14 sources)

• Eight level deep hardware stack

• Direct, indirect and relative addressing modes

• Power-on Reset (POR)

• Power-up Timer (PWRT) and

Oscillator Start-up Timer (OST)

• Watchdog Timer (WDT) with its own on-chip RC

oscillator for reliable operation

• Programmable code protection

• Power saving SLEEP mode

• Selectable oscillator options

• Low power, high speed CMOS FLASH/EEPROM

technology

• Fully static design

• In-Circuit Serial Programming. (ICSP) via two

pins

• Single 5V In-Circuit Serial Programming capability

• In-Circuit Debugging via two pins

• Processor read/write access to program memory

• Wide operating voltage range: 2.0V to 5.5V

• High Sink/Source Current: 25 mA

• Commercial, Industrial and Extended temperature

ranges

• Low-power consumption:

- < 0.6 mA typical @ 3V, 4 MHz

- 20 μA typical @ 3V, 32 kHz

-         < 1 μA typical standby current

 

The peripheral features of the PIC16F877 are:

 

• Timer0: 8-bit timer/counter with 8-bit prescaler

• Timer1: 16-bit timer/counter with prescaler,

can be incremented during SLEEP via external

crystal/clock

• Timer2: 8-bit timer/counter with 8-bit period

register, prescaler and postscaler

• Two Capture, Compare, PWM modules

Capture is 16-bit, max. resolution is 12.5 ns

- Compare is 16-bit, max. resolution is 200 ns

- PWM max. resolution is 10-bit

• 10-bit multi-channel Analog-to-Digital converter

• Synchronous Serial Port (SSP) with SPI. (Master

mode) and I2C. (Master/Slave)

• Universal Synchronous Asynchronous Receiver

Transmitter (USART/SCI) with 9-bit address

detection

• Parallel Slave Port (PSP) 8-bits wide, with

external RD, WR and CS controls (40/44-pin only)

• Brown-out detection circuitry for

Brown-out Reset (BOR)

 

The Pinouts of the PIC16F877 is given in Figure 3.0-2

 

 

Figure-3.0-1 PIC16F877 Block Diagram

 

 

 

Figure 3.0-2 Pin diagram of PIC16F877

 

3.1.   Flash PIC development board

 

Usually, a microcontroller by itself is not sufficient to perform the intended tasks. For instance, an oscillator chip is necessary to time the programmed instructions. In order to investigate the capabilities or to test a given microcontroller, obviously it is vital to build the proper circuitary. Example: potentiometer and a power supply to simulate analog inputs or LEDs to simulate the digital outputs. Hence, some hardware and sofware vendors provide the microcontroller with the supplemantary circuit elements on the same breadboard. These boards are called Development Boards. One can also build a development board himself/herself if he/she is willing to go through the painsaking process of building the circuit.

Figure-3.1-1 FlashPIC Development Board

 

The development board used in the series of experiments is Flash PIC development board. (Figure3.1-1) It has the following features:

 

- RS232 through a 9-Pin D-Shell as well as screw terminals and a jumper header.

- Up to 32K words of In-System Programmable FLASH memory with up to 256

bytes of EEPROM and up to 1.5K of Internal RAM (depending on processor

selection).

- Up to 8, 10 bit, Analog Inputs, using either internal or user supplied reference.

- 9 I/O controlled LEDs, 8 of which are jumper selectable.

- 32KHz “watch” crystal for on-board Real-Time operations.

- A universal clock socket allows for “canned oscillators”, as well as a variety of

crystals, ceramic resonators, and passive terminations.

- 0.1” centered headers provide for simple connection to the processor special

function pins and I/O.

- A 6-pin, ICD connection is provided for in-system programming and debugging.

This connection is directly compatible with the Microchip ICD, ICD2 and CCS

ICD-S programming hardware. Flash PICs can also be programmed through

RS232 using an appropriate boot loader application.

- On-board regulation allows for power inputs from 8-38VDC with an LED power

indicator.

- Termination is provided for 5VDC output at 250ma

 

3.2.   CCS PIC-C compiler

The CCS PCW compiler is specially designed to meet the special needs of the PICmicro MCU controllers. These tools allow developers to quickly design application software for these controllers in a highly readable, high-level language.

The compilers has some limitations when compared to a more traditional C

compiler. The hardware limitations make many traditional C compilers

ineffective. As an example of the limitations, the compilers will not permit

pointers to constant arrays. This is due to the separate code/data segments in

the PICmicro MCU hardware and the inability to treat ROM areas as data. On

the other hand, the compilers have knowledge about the hardware limitations

and do the work of deciding how to best implement your algorithms. The

compilers can efficiently implement normal C constructs, input/output operations

and bit twiddling operations.

      The compiler can output 8 bit hex, 16 bit hex, and binary files. Two listing formats

are available. Standard format resembles the Microchip tools and may be

required by some third-party tools. The simple format is easier to read. The

debug file may either be a Microchip .COD file or Advanced Transdata .MAP file.

All file formats and extensions are selected via the Options|File Formats menu

option in the Windows IDE.

      The usage of the copiler is explained in Section 2.0 Getting started. The reference book “Embedded C Programming and the Microchip PIC” comes with a demo version of the compiler. 

 

3.3.   ICD-S Debugger/Programmer

The ICD-S programmer is the hardware/firmware interface to burn the .hex files to the Microchip PIC. The ICD unit works with CCS's PCW debugger or CCS's stand-alone ICD control software. CCS's PCW debugger is a very robust debugger integrated with PCW, and provides very detailed debugging information at the C level. The stand-alone control software allows you to quickly program target chips using ICD's ICSP. The control software also lets you update the ICD unit's firmware without having to remove the chip from the ICD unit. (Using these software tools requires you to have loaded the CCS-ICD firmware onto the ICD unit, which is loaded by default).

Authors note 01/22/04 : I found it odd that prllc.com does not provide a freeware program like “AVR bootloader.exe” for FlashPIC Development board as they do for Atmel AVR development board, that would enable programming the chip via serial communication connector P1 in-built to the development board. I don`t think that Development board and Compiler vendors should force the costumers to buy products like ICD-S where an option like programming via serial link exists. I have seen a program in http://sjeffroy.free.fr/Prog__PIC/BootLoader/bootloader.html which seems like it might work given the fact that bootloader file “loader.hex” pre-exists on the chip. Personally, I did not try running this program and programming the chip via RS-232.

 

 

Figure-3.3-1 FlashPIC Development Board

 

 

 

3.4.   The Reference Book: Embedded C Programming and the Microchip PIC by Barnett, Cox and O’Cull

This book is a good guide for introducing the microcontroller technology. First chapter is dedicated to teaching basic C programming however, this book shouldn’t be considered a C programming handbook. One should always have a book like: Teach yourself C by Zhang ISBN 0-672-31861 as a C programming reference guide for beginners.

 

This book is designed to teach C language programming as it applies to embedded microcontrollers and to fuel knowledge in the application of the Microchip family of PIC microcontrollers. Coverage begins with a step-by-step exploration of the C language showing readers how to create C language programs to solve problems. PIC processors are then studied, from basic architecture to all of the standard peripheral devices included in the microcontrollers. Numerous worked-out example programs demonstrate common uses for each of the peripherals. Readers are subsequently introduced to the built-in functions available in C, to speed their programming and problem solving. Finally, readers are taken through use of the C Compiler, and to help custom learn to efficiently develop projects.

 

Image

Figure-3.4-1 Embedded C Programming and the Microchip PIC

Included with the book is a CDROM containing samples all of the example programs from the book as well as an evaluation version of the CCS-PICC Compiler.

 

Author`s note 01/22/04 : In the first examples and projects in chapter 1, functions like “scanf” and “printf” are used that require prior knowledge to interface the board through RS-232 which is introduced in the late chapters of the book. It might be discouraging for the student not being able to do the first project of the book, hands-on. Although I was able to find answers to most of my questions about using the C compiler and the hardware however, I had to do a lot of skipping between chapters and Appendixes to find these answers which was time consuming. In general it is a nice and descriptive text book.

 

4.      Experiments

The most quick and effective way of learning a new topic is, having hands on experience. In this section we will conduct some experiments using the FlashPIC Development board to which would give us a jump start on in PIC usage.

 

4.1.   LED Experiment

 

The digital I/O and the timers will be discussed with this experiment. The program will count from 0 to 255 and output the binary equivalent of this number to PortD every 2 seconds. The digital I/O peripherals are discussed in detail in the next experiment “Dipswitch”. In this experiment we will focus on the usage timers.

            Timers and counters are one of the most commonly used perpheral in a microcontroller. They can be used to measure time periods, speed and provide output signals in a specified rate.

            The PIC16F877 has 4 timers timer0, timer1, timer2 and watch dog timer. Timer0 and timer2 are 8 bit timers and timer1 is a 16bit timer. The inportant issue is to know when the counter reaches the maximum value (255 in 8 bit timers and 65,535 is 16bit timers) and rolls over.

 

The watch dog timer is a safety device. When an unepected event occurs, the watch dog timer resets the microcontroller. In this experiment we will use the watch dog timer as our timer to time the digital output.

 

#use delay(clock=10000000, RESTART_WDT)

 

The command line above, is used to tell the compiler to insert an appropriate code to automatically reload the WDT during delay functions.

 

“delay_ms(2000)”  command line is used to place a delay the event 2000ms in every cycle of the while loop. “output_d(z)” command line is used to output the digital number through portD.

 

Instructions:

 

  1. We type the code in Figure4.1-1, compile it and program the chip as explained in Section 2. The code can also be downloaded from here ledwdt.c.

Figure4.1-1 The source code for the LED experiment

  1. We can unplug the ICD-S and run the experiment and observe the progress of the count every 2 seconds.

]

4.2.   Dip switch Experiment

The goal of this experiment is to illustrate digital inputs and outputs. An 8 bit binary number is introduced using an 8-position dip switch. The input representing the 8 bit digital number is given through the PIC16F877 through portB using the dipswitch circuit. The software outputs this binary number via portD LEDs.

 

There are 5 I/O ports in the in the PIC16F877. The individual bits and the whole channel can set to digital inputs or outputs. The following commands are used to set the ports to output:

set_tris_d( 0x00 )

set_tris_b( 0xFF )

 

With these command lines, port D and port B is set to output and input respectively. The following commands to read and input from port B and write it to port D respectively.

z=input_b()

output_d(z)

The following command is also used to activate the port B pullups.

port_b_pullups(TRUE)

The procedure for the experiment:

  1. Place the dipswitch, (4.2-1) 8 pin header and single pin header as illustrated in Figure4.2-2 on the component side of the board and solder them on the solder side of the board. Only the holes which have been used are illustrated in Figure 4.2-2.

 

Figure-4.2-1 The 8 Position Dip Switch

 

 

 

 

 Figure-4.2-2 The layout of the dipswitch breadboard

 

  1. One side of the switch is jumped together and tied to common ground. The single pin header is jumped to the common ground of the development board using an alligotor clip. The other side of the switch is tied to Port B using a ribbon cable. See Figure-4.2-3 and Figure-4.2-4.

Figure-4.2-3 Schematics of the Dip Switch Circuit

4.2-4 Connection details of the dip switch circuit to the Development Board

4.2-5 The experiment setup

 

  1. We type the code in Figure4.2-6, compile it and program the chip as explained in Section 2. The code can also be downloaded from here dip.c. Note that the I/O process is located in an infinite loop with the while(1) command line. Hence, the program is constantly reading from port B and writing to Port D.

4.2-6 The source code for the dip experiment

 

  1. We can unplug the ICD-S and run the experiment and observe the binary numbers change as we change the dip switch positions.

 

4.3.   ADC Temperature Measurement

In this experiment, the usage of the in built 10-bit Analog to Digital Converter will be demonstrated. The temperature sensor LM35 is wired to channel 1 of the ADC port; portA. Then this temperature sensor is dropped in boiling water which is left in room temperature to cool down and the temperature is read and recorded by the PIC16F877 every 5 minutes. Since the LM35 is not water proof, the chip is placed in a container and the container shall be sealed.

The procedure for the experiment:

  1. Wire the LM35 to channel 1 of PortA and the power supply (9V battery) The pin out of the LM35 is given in Figure 4.3-1. The wiring shematic is given in Figure 4.3-2. Jumpers are placed on the unused analog channels to prevent the cross talk between channels and noise.

Figure 4.3-1 Pin out of the LM35 Temperature Sensor

 

Figure 4.3-2 The wiring schematics for the temperature sensor experiment

 

  1. Type the following code (Figure 4.3-3) and burn it on the chip after compiling it. By implementing the line “#device ADC=10”, the analog to digital conversion is set to 10bit resolution.  The LM35 outputs the temperature with the sensitivity of 10mv/oC (Example: 25 oC corresponds to 250mv). The range of the ADC of the PIC Development Board is 0 to 5V and the ADC conversion is 10bits. Hence, the resolution is 210-1=1023. So the formula for analog to digital conversion would be;

Temperature in Celsius = 5.00 * Voltage read from LM35 * 100.00/1023.00

 

Figure 4.3-3 Source code for the temperature sensor experiment

  1. The LM35 is not waterproof. Hence, we need to place it in a plastic sphere (like the ones in the bubblegum machines) and epoxy the hole to seal the sphere. Before sealing the sphere for good, we need to put some weight (Example: coins nuts and bolts) in the sphere to prevent the sphere from floating in the water. (See Figure 4.3-4) We need to keep the water level low so that we do not soak the wires coming out of the plastic sphere in hot water.

Figure 4.3-4 Overall experiment setup with the LM35 sealed

 

  1. In this application, the RS-232 communications will be used as the data interface between the PC and the PIC16F877 development board. Notice that PIC Flash Development board comes with 2 separate means of  serial communications which are marked in Figure 4.3-5.

Figure 4.3-5 RS-232 Communication pins

Due to the convenience of using a standard RS-232 cable one would prefer to use the standard DB-9 connector which is labeled P1 however, the transmit and receive pins for this cable/connector do not match the transmit and receive pins for the standard RS-232 cable so, we have to use the screw terminal RS-232 communications which is labeled RS232. So we cut the female connector off the standard RS-232 cable and strip the connector down to its shell. (Figure 4.3-6)

Figure 4.3-6 DB9 Female connector

            Now we can solder the Receive(R-pin number 3 ), Transmit(T-pin number 2) and Ground (G-pin number 5) pins according to the wiring schematic given in Figure 4.3-7. Keep in mind that this wiring scheme is given from the front view of the connector. The picture of the wiring is in Figure 4.3-8.

 

Figure 4.3-7 Wiring Schematics of the RS-232 communications

Figure 4.3-8 View of the Development board with RS-232 communications established

 

  1. After checking the wiring and making sure the LM35 is sealed properly, we can power up the development board and plug in the RS-232 serial communications cable to the computer and start the hyper terminal application which will be used for  data acquisition. The usual path of the hyper terminal is start menu>Programs>Accessories>Communications>hyperterminal. Settings of the hyper terminal communications is given in Figure 4.3-9.

 

Figure 4.3-9 Hyper terminal Communications Settings

Now we are ready to acquire data. Due to the while loop we have implemented in the source code, it will take 5minutes to acquire our first set of data. It would be convenient to delete the ten “delay_ms(30000)” lines and put a single delay_ms(500) to test if we are acquiring meaningful data. Depending on the applications unfortunately, RS-232 is somewhat a troublesome communication link. If you experience problems with communications, make sure the ICD-S software is not running and ICD-S is not plugged in the development board, try connecting and disconnecting until communications is established. If there are problems with the acquired data, we should try recycling power of the development board and rebooting the PC. A screen shot of the hyper terminal screen is given in Figure 4.3-10.

Figure 4.3-10 Screen Shot of the hyper terminal screen

6.      The values recorded through hyper terminal screen can be saved as a text file and be opened in MS Excel and plotted. The results of the experiment are given in Figure4.3-11. Notice that the first and second values of the curve is 52 and 79. Since the water is boiled we would expect the first reading to be 100oC. However, the coins and the plastic bulb, which is at room temperature initially, absorbs some of the energy therefore the temperature drops significantly and reaches a steady state 79 oC before decaying.

Figure 4.3-11 Cooling curve of the boiled water in ADC thermistor experiment

 

 

4.4.   Open Loop and Close Loop Temperature Control

As a final experiment we will get a chance to deploy all the features of PIC16F877, which we previously have investigated. In addition to these features we will also learn how the usage of a 8-bit Digital to Analog Converter (DAC).

As in the ADC experiment, the temperature sensor LM35 is placed into a cup of water. This cup is also exposed to hot air from a blow dryer which can be considered as a disturbance to the system intended to be controlled. Speed of a PC fan is regulated, to keep the water temperature at 27oC. Obviously, we should not ignore the effects of the natural convection as an additional disturbance. Two different controls approaches are used while regulating the temperature:

q       Closed Loop Control: The fan speed is adjusted according to the temperature feedback every time step. The generic block diagram of the control system is given in Figure 4.4.1.

Figure 4.4-1 Generic Block Diagram of Closed Loop Temperature Control System

 

q       Open Loop (Bang Bang) Control: The fan is either turned on at maximum speed or turned off depending on temperature feedback exceeding the temperature goal. Actually, this control system can also be considered to be close loop since the control system responds to a feedback, however since the feedback only triggers a switching operation, it is considered an open loop operation. The generic block diagram of is given in Figure 4.4-2.

 

 

Figure 4.4-2 Generic Block Diagram of Open Loop Temperature Control System

The procedure of the experiment:

1.      As the first step of the experiment, we will build our DAC/LF353 Op-Amp Circuit.

A schematic of the DAC /Op-Amp circuit is given in Figure 4.4-3.  The theory of operation for this circuit is that when an eight bit word is sent to the digital to analog converter (DAC), the DAC outputs a current that is defined in equation 2.1.

Equation 4.4. 1

 

The output current is then fed into the op amps of the LF353 integrated circuit.  The output from the LF353 circuit is defined:

Equation 4.4. 2

 

The DAC/LF353 card takes a digital word as an input, and outputs a proportional voltage.  In this application the digitalword of 181 will result in an output voltage of 4.2 V, given a reference voltage of +12 V. 181 corresponds to fan’s minimum speed. Digitalword of 255 will produce output of 7.5V which is the maximum speed of the fan. All the pins of  PortD of the PIC16F877 is set for output and they are wired to the DAC/LF353 circuit. Illustration of DAC/LF353 circuit is given in Figure4.4-4.

 

Figure 4.4-3 Schematics of the DAC/LF353 Op-amp circuit

Figure 4.4-4 DAC/LF353 Op-amp circuit

 

2.      As the second step we can build our TIP31 Power Transistor Circuit. A schematic of the TIP31 power transistor circuit may be found as Figure 4.4-5  This circuit is necessary because motors do not run on voltage, rather they run on current.  The current is obtained from an external power supply, which is added proportionally to the voltage that is input to the TIP31 circuit.  The TIP31 works by reading a reference voltage from its base pin (b), then an equivalent voltage supplied by the a source attached to the collector (c), is allowed to pass to the emitter (e). This allows for an external power supply to be regulated by a low current circuit.  The DAC/LF353 Op-amp circuit is illustrated in Figure 4.4-6.

 

Figure 4.4-5 Schematics of the Power Transistor TIP31 Circuit

 

 

Figure 4.4-6 Power Transistor TIP31 Circuit

 

3.      For this experiment, as we review the schematics, it is evident that we need a power supply which can give us the following voltages:12V,-12V and 5V. We can use a common PC power supply for this application. However we need to make a slight modification to the power supply. The PC power supplies are switching supplies. Hence, they require proper  amount of load to be operational. The following site is a nice guide for modifying PC power supplies for general use: http://web2.murraystate.edu/andy.batts/ps/powersupply.htm. The main idea is to add a 10ohm 10watt resistor across 5V and common to apply the necessary load for operation. However, the resistor gets extremely hot; so, it would be appropriate to apply a heat sink on the resistor and place the resistor in front of the power supply fan  (Figure-4.4-7) to avoid resistor failure which would eventually lead to power supply failure. 

Figure 4.4-7 Power supply with load applied

 

4.      Now we can start assembling the circuit. The reference voltage of DAC/LF353 is tied to +12V of the power supply. The grounds of all the components (Development board, LM35, DAC/LF353, TIP31 Power transistor circuit/DC Fan) are tied to the power supply ground. The output voltage of Pin7 of LF353 is tied to the TIP31 base. The LM35 is wired as described in section 4.3 ADC Experiment. This time instead of using a 9V battery to power the LM35, we can use 5V power supply. The RS-232 communications cable is wired as described in the ADC experiment in section 4.3 and is plugged into the computer. We also need a blow-dryer for this experiment as a disturbance to the system as described above. While doing the wiring, preparing the hardware necessary for this experiment, be sure to check the wiring before putting power to it. Each sub-assembly should be tested separately before putting the experiment setup together as a whole. For instance, once the DAC/LF353 circuit is prepared, run the dip.c program and check if the voltages correspond to the digitalwords using a voltmeter. The Experiment setup is illustrated in Figure-4.4-8.

Figure-4.4-8 The Experiment Setup

 

5.      We are ready to program the chip. The code given in Figure4.4-9 is used for the close loop application. The code is also provided in file project3.c. There aren’t any new commands introduced with this code. The digitalword=181 can be considered as the threshold value which gives 4.2V and generates enough current through the TIP31 circuit so that the fan rotation starts. Furthermore, the digitalword=255 generates 7.5V which generates the highest speed using the hardware listed in this section. So, we can control the speed through the digital word ranging from 181 to 255. The resolution is 255-181=74 steps. We use Kp=2.5 as the proportional gain of the control system. This seems to be an ideal value for the operational range and the cooling load involved.

 

Figure4.4-9

The source code for the Open Loop (Bang-Bang ) Control is given in Figure4.4-10. It is also available with file project3bb.c. The temp_comparator variable compares the temperature feedback with the target temperature and switches the fan on at full speed or off.

 Figure4.4-10

6.      We are ready to program the chip and start the experiments. In the first experiment, the initial temperature of the water is chosen to be 42oC. As stated before, the target temperature is 27 oC. In the second experiment the, the water is heated from 16 oC to the target temperature 27oC. These two experiments are conducted both using the close loop and open loop program. The data recording is performed via the hyperterminal screen as described in Section 4.3. All the recorded data is also provided in Appendix A in Excel Spreadsheets.

Cooling Experiments:

In Figure4.4-11 and Figure4.4-12, the results Close Loop and Open Loop cooling are given respectively. While reviewing the graphs, keep in mind that, the negative speed commands mean digital words smaller than 181 which correspond to motor currents smaller than the threshold level for the DC Fan to move. So, the DC Fan does not move with the negative speed commands. These values are given only to illustrate how digitalword changes with varying  temperature level. The closed loop system cools down to the steady state between 500sec and 2200sec. So, it takes roughly 1700 seconds for it to cool down. However for the open loop system, since the fan is commanded to its maximum speed while the temperature is higher than the target, it takes much less time (1800-500=1300sec) for it to cool down to the desired steady state. In the closed loop system, the system seems to be critically damped since there is steady state error and no overshoot. We can increase the gain and check the overshoot if a faster responding system with minimal steady state error is desired.

                 

Figure4.4-11 Cooling Curve for Close Loop Fan Speed Control

 

                       

Figure4.4-12 Cooling Curve for Open Loop Fan Speed Control

Since in the open loop cooling, temperature feedback is intermittently under the influence of noise, the control system becomes unstable especially around 1000 second mark. If the effects of noise becomes more significant, a low pass filter can be added to the circuit; but in this case the effect is minimal. Since the fan is either turned on or off, the fan commanded speed takes values either 0 or 74 as we converge to the steady state. One might find it difficult to follow what speed commands are given at each time-step to the DC fan at steady state temperature. The Excel Sheets given in Appendix A can be used for more thorough analysis of the data.

 

Heating Experiments:

In Figure4.4-13 and Figure4.4-14, the results Close Loop and Open Loop cooling are given respectively. Since in both close loop and open loop system the fan is off before converging to steady state, the rise time for both systems are roughly the same which is approximately 1000sec. We observe intermittent electrical noise problems which do not impact the control system performance significantly. In close loop control mode, around 2300sec mark, after the system reaches steady state, the hairdryer is moved closer to the cup, in order to experiment increasing the effect of the disturbance. 60 seconds later the temperature starts increasing. Roughly 100seconds later, the control system starts to stabilize the increasing temperature and around 2500second mark, the temperature is back to target temperature. This is a good indication that the system responds very slowly to varying disturbances.

 

 

Figure4.4-13 Heating Curve for Open Loop Fan Speed Control

 

Figure4.4-14 Heating Curve for Open Loop Fan Speed Control

7.      For the heating, the performance of the open loop and close loop systems are very similar. As the results are reviewed for cooling , the close loop control system seems to be critically damped. Obviously, we can improve the rise time by increasing the gain.  Since we get a better rise time for the open loop system and it takes less time to reach steady state, it is more preferable over the Closed Loop system with proportional gain of Kp=2.5.

 

5.      Where do we go from here?

 

Now that we have explored basics of the PIC16F877 and the compiler, we are ready to conduct more advanced experiments. Good luck!

 

Note for Dr Oh`s student who will replicate this effort: Please don’t hesitate to contact me from cy56@drexel.edu and phone:215 378 39 88 if you have any questions. Leave a message and I definitely will return your call.